The NHL has ignited a firestorm of debate among fans and analysts alike with its recent ranking of Connor Bedard as the eighth-best player under 25. This startling announcement, made by the NHL Network in late August 2025, has left many questioning the criteria behind such a controversial decision. Bedard, a Chicago Blackhawks center and the first overall pick in the 2023 NHL Draft, has quickly established himself as a generational talent, yet his placement has sparked outrage across social media.
Bedard’s impressive resume includes winning the Calder Trophy and racking up 128 points in just 150 games. His performance during the 2024-25 season saw him accumulate 67 points, including 23 goals and 44 assists. Despite these achievements, the NHL Network placed defenseman Rasmus Dahlin at the top of the list, citing his 277 career assists and significant playoff experience as key factors. Dahlin’s ranking reflects not only his individual statistics but also his contributions to a playoff-contending team, a stark contrast to Bedard’s Blackhawks, who missed the postseason.
The immediate backlash from fans has been intense, with many deeming the ranking an “absolute joke.” Critics argue that Bedard’s individual accomplishments warrant a higher position, while others question the overall methodology of the rankings. Analysts have pointed out that the absence of playoff experience may have influenced Bedard’s lower placement, as many players ranked above him have demonstrated their ability to perform in crucial games.
As discussions continue, the NHL Network has yet to provide clarity on the ranking criteria, leaving fans and experts alike in a state of confusion. This controversy highlights the ongoing tension between established players with playoff success and emerging talents like Bedard, whose potential remains untapped in a rebuilding franchise. The conversation surrounding Bedard’s ranking underscores not only his individual success but also the broader narrative of young talent in the NHL and the expectations that come with it. The debate is far from over, and as the season approaches, all eyes will be on Bedard and the Blackhawks to see how this ranking impacts their performance on the ice.
